A web designer asked owners on r/smallbusiness what made them regret hiring someone to build their website. One store owner's answer is the one I would print out. They owned everything, so that part was fine. The problem: "It looked great in screenshots and ran fine with ten test products. The moment we went live with a few hundred real ones, search crawled, checkout broke on certain phones, and every small change took a week because it was built on a theme they had hacked to pieces."
They named two red flags they now take seriously. First, the agency "had no live client site I could test myself. Screenshots and staging links only." Second, "nobody ever said no. Every request was yes, yes, yes, and the timeline quietly doubled." Their advice: "A good one will tell you which of your ideas are bad before you pay for them."
The lesson
Screenshots are not a website. Judge a builder by a real client site under real traffic, on your own phone, and by whether they ever tell you no.
Why it matters more now
Building a site that looks good has become cheap; a page can be generated in an afternoon. What has not become cheap is a site that stays fast with real products, works on every phone, and reads clearly enough that a customer's AI assistant can find it and describe what you sell. The gap between the two is where owners lose money now.
Do this before you sign
- Ask for three live client sites, open them on your own phone, search, add something to a basket, and read a product page. If you only get screenshots or staging links, walk away.
- Ask the builder which of your ideas they would talk you out of. A yes to everything is a warning, not a service.
- Agree in writing who owns the domain, the hosting account and the site files, and that you can change a phone number yourself without emailing anyone.
- Already have a site? Run the free AI crawler check and the AI visibility check to see whether it can be read and found at all.

